Umme Kulsoom ka nikah kya waaqeyi omar se hua?

Ibn Abdul Bir ne apni kitab Al-Isti’aab (v.1, p.425) mein jo ke Sahaba ke baare mein sabse pehli likhi gayi kitaabon mein se hai, likha:
"Muhammad bin Jafar bin Abi Talib, yeh wahi hain jo Umme Kulsoom bint Ali bin Abi Talib se Umar bin Khattab ki wafat ke baad shaadi ki thi."

AlBeri ne Al-Jawhara (v.1, p.205) mein Muhammad bin Jafar (Al-Tayyar) ke baare mein kaha:
"...Aur Muhammad, woh Abi Talib ke shabeeh hain aur wahi hain jo Umme Kulsoom bint Ali se shaadi karte hain."

Ibn AlAtheer ne Asad Al-Gaba (v.2, p.481) mein likha:
"Muhammad bin Jafar bin Abi Talib:... Muhammad apne chacha Abi Talib ke shabeeh hain aur wahi hain jo Umme Kulsoom bint Ali se shaadi karte hain."

Imam Ahmad Al-Hasan se ek baar sawaal kiya gaya:
"Sunnion ka dawa hai ke Sayyida Umme Kulsoom (a.s) ki shaadi Umar ke saath hui thi, lekin hum yakin ke saath kehte hain ke yeh jhoot hai, kyun ke yeh riwayat ki gayi hai ke Umar bin Atheena ne kaha: Maine Abi Abdullah (a.s) se poocha: log humse behas karte hain aur kehte hain ke Ameerul Momineen (a.s) ne apni beti Umme Kulsoom ko falan shakhs se shaadi karai. Imam uth kar baithe aur farmaya:
"Kya woh yeh kehte hain? Jo log yeh daawa karte hain woh log hain jo hidayat ke raaste par nahi hain. SubhanAllah! Kya Ameerul Momineen (a.s) apni beti ko bacha nahi sakte thay? Unhone jhoot bola hai aur jo unka daawa hai woh nahi hua."
(Bihar al-Anwar, vol.42, p.88)

Woh log yeh dawa karte hain aur agar Umar uske shauhar nahi thay, to phir kaun tha? To kya aap humein bata sakte hain, aye mere aaqa? Allah ki qasam, humara sawaal shak se nahi hai, balki yaqeen mein izafa karne ke liye poocha hai.

Muhammad Shareef, Morocco

Imam Ahmad Al-Hasan ne jawab diya:
"Umme Kulsoom ka shauhar Muhammad bin Jafar bin Abi Talib hai. Lekin, Allah aap par reham kare, aap kyun unhe apne paas kheenchne dete hain? Aur iska haqq aur baatil se kya taluq hai? Kya Firon ki biwi jo nabi ke nasal se thi duniya ki behtareen aurton mein se nahi thi, jaisa ke nabi ne bayan kiya? Kya Nooh ki biwi aur Lut ki biwi kafir nahi thi?
Aur agar aap yeh keh bhi dein ke uska shauhar falan tha, to kya woh aapke jawab se mutma’in ho jayenge aur apni banawati baaton se baaz aa jayenge?

Agar aap logon ke saath behas jeetna chahte hain aur un par daleel tamam karna chahte hain, to khilafat ke jaanne ke usool ka daleel pesh karein."